Quick Links

Service Guide 2012 PersonalFN Service Guide  2013

 


Home Loan DILEMMA:To prepay or not to prepay?     (04-Oct-2010 )



Along with planning your retirement, and funding your children’s higher education, owning your own home is one of the key life goals for most individuals.
With rising interest rates, many people who have home loans are considering whether or not it is recommended to prepay their home loans so as to not incur even higher EMI payments going forward.


But before rushing into the decision, there are a few things to look into when considering home loan prepayment, and these are explained below:


  1. Prepayment & Interest Savings

    First, what is prepayment? Prepayment is when you decide to pay an additional (over and above your regular EMIs) amount of principal of your loan back, ahead of time. This reduces the principal outstanding, reducing your EMIs or remaining loan tenure.

    Banks typically levy a prepayment charge of about 2 - 3% of the outstanding loan amount, if you prepay above a certain amount, or if you are switching lenders.

    Most banks will allow part prepayment up to a certain limit without levying on you any prepayment charge.
    In some cases like with SBI, if the prepayment is out of your own income and not borrowed money, you can prepay any amount without incurring any penalty. You can opt to partly prepay your loan regularly, for example every 3 months, constantly reducing your principal outstanding, bringing down the amount of interest you will owe the bank. Remember, the longer the tenure of the loan, the more the interest you are paying, so part prepayments are a good way of saving on interest payments.

    An illustration will help explain the point:

    Mr. Shah has taken a loan 5 years ago, and wants to reduce his debt burden by making part prepayments.

    Initial Loan Taken Rs. 20 lakh
    Tenure of Loan 20 years
    Loan tenure elapsed 5 years
    Current EMI Rs. 22,022
    Current interest rate 12% p.a.

    If Mr. Shah were to continue with his EMIs, he would repay the following amounts:

    Total interest payment (nominal value) Rs. 21.29 lakhs
    Total Principal Repaid (outstanding principal) Rs. 18.35 lakhs

    (These figures can be arrived at from the amortization table in his loan policy document which his bank has to provide to him.)


    Thus, his Rs. 20 lakh loan would cost him approximately Rs. 40 lakh over 20 years, assuming a constant interest rate of 12% for the sake of calculations.
    Understandably, Mr. Shah wants to reduce the debt burden.

    He can save enough through the year by cutting down his expenses and channelizing his bonus towards home loan prepayments, to pay an additional 3 EMIs every year.

    If he does so his payments come down to:

    Total interest payment (nominal value) Rs. 12.03 lakhs
    Total Principal Repaid (outstanding principal) Rs. 18.35 lakhs

    He saves approximately Rs. 9 lakhs in interest payments – Certainly a tidy sum!

    Also remember, any prepayments towards home loan will be considered for tax benefit under Section 80C as they are repayment of principal of the home loan – an added benefit!

    Additionally, by doing so, he would not incur any prepayment penalty as this is below the maximum penalty incurring limit levied by his bank, and he can reduce his loan tenure by close to 6 years. He can repay his total loan in approximately 14 years instead of 20.

    But, in case you are prepaying above the penalty free limit and the bank is levying a prepayment charge on you, there are two things to keep in mind:

    1. Negotiate

      Prepayment charges are not necessarily final – you can negotiate with your bank and if you have good credit history they may reduce or even waive the prepayment fee. If your loan has a lower interest rate than the current rate of interest (if you have taken a fixed home loan) then banks would be more open to letting you prepay and waiving the fee. Also note, in some cases, if you are prepaying out of your own savings rather than switching lenders, then there might be no prepayment charge applicable, provided it has been more than 3 years since you have taken the loan.


    2. Calculate

      Do check your loan amortization table to see how much interest you will be saving by prepaying your loan, and compare this to the prepayment charge you will have to face. If interest saved is greater than the prepayment penalty, you can consider prepaying your loan. You will probably find that the savings on interest payments are so large compared to prepayment penalty, that it makes more sense to prepay.


  2. Opportunity Cost

    Suppose, instead of prepaying your loan with additional lump sums or a higher EMI, you were to invest the money into an equity mutual fund (provided this is suitable to your risk appetite and goal time horizon) and let it earn returns over the years.
    Which one would be more beneficial to you?

    Let’s continue with the above illustration:

    Mr. Shah’s current EMI is Rs. 22,022.
    He has 15 years left on the loan, at 12% interest.
    If he increases his payments by prepaying approximately additional Rs. 66,000 per year i.e. Rs. 5,500 per month, he saves Rs. 9 lakhs in interest and pays his entire loan off in 14 years total i.e. 9 years more.

    He can avail tax benefits under Section 80C up to Rs. 1 lakh p.a. on the prepayments (assuming the entire Section 80C limit is available).
    He can also avail tax benefit up to Rs. 1,50,000 p.a. (provided the house is self occupied) under Section 24 on the interest repayments.
    This is a sure fact – there is no market related risk involved here.

    However, instead of doing this, suppose he invests the Rs. 5,500 per month into an equity mutual fund for 9 years.
    Assuming a 15% rate of return on equity, his SIP of Rs. 5,500 would earn him approximately Rs. 12.58 lakhs.
    This is dependent on the equity rate of return and does involve risk.
    Currently long term gains on equity are not taxable, and so there is no tax burden on this option. Here, it would make more sense for Mr. Shah to invest the money rather than channelizing it towards prepayments. This is because the assumed return on equity (15% p.a.) is higher than the interest rate on the loan (12% p.a.).

    If Mr. Shah had a short term investment horizon and a lower risk appetite, he would invest in debt rather than equity, earn a lower post tax rate of interest on the debt investment than he would be paying on the home loan, and thus it would make more sense for him to prepay the loan.


  3. Other Points to Note:

    1. Before prepaying any loan, make sure you have enough funds left aside to meet any emergency needs that might arise


    2. It is a myth that prepayment is only beneficial in the initial years of the loan. When you prepay you are prepaying principal and reducing the interest burden. This is beneficial at all points in the loan tenure – only more so in the beginning.


    3. If you have more than one loan, prepay the high interest rate loan first.


    4. Often, a question people ask when considering prepaying the home loan is to do with tax benefits. But remember that it is better to earn more and pay more tax than earn less just to pay less tax. When prepaying a home loan, there are only two things you should keep in mind:

      - Interest Saving on prepayment
      - Opportunity Cost.


    Also remember, this advice is general.

    When dealing with a home loan or any major liability, please consult your Financial Planner / Investment Consultant for specific advice.

    You can also write to us at info@personalfn.com or call at:


Mumbai
+91 - 22 - 6136 1200
Share |



16  Responses to
  • Rakesh
    Updated on
    Mar 10, 2011
      Good article ..Thanks
  • vinod
    Updated on
    Jun 02, 2011
      very informative
  • Jitendra
    Updated on
    Jun 13, 2011
      Good one !
  • Shridhar
    Updated on
    Jun 30, 2011
      Good Article
  • Himadri
    Updated on
    Jan 12, 2012
      Well articulated article. Good work!
  • Satchell
    Updated on
    Jan 19, 2012
      Well macadamia nuts, how about that.
  • krishna
    Updated on
    Mar 07, 2012
      Its Good article ..
  • Paresh
    Updated on
    Mar 21, 2012
      I liked the article. Points well taken and written.
  • R K
    Updated on
    Apr 01, 2012
      Pre payment of home loan is beneficial if interest burden is more than 150000/- pa (i.e. Max exemption limit for IT ) and the Lonee is not in higher tax bracket. Moreover, the repayment of loan by a salaried Lonee is made from his future earning and not from his existing corpus which will continue earning interest if invested intelligently. Therefore, before deciding on how much loan should be prepaid, one must look into all aspects and calculate the net saving due to prepayment of home loan. 
  • jagdish
    Updated on
    Apr 01, 2012
      useful tips. it cleared my dilemma.
  • kishore
    Updated on
    Apr 24, 2012
      I have taken a Home loan of rs 9 lakhs from Bank of Maharashtra for 20 yrs @ rate of 10.25% from july 2007 onwards, it is almost 5 years, & i have paid more than 5lakhs & 30 thousands, but my loan balance still is around 8 laks 60 thouasnds.  if i wish to sell this property within 2 0r 3 months, what amount i need to pay to the bank to close the loan, shall it be 8.60 lakhs or they will only charge the interest for the total number of months ( 62 months) & adjusts the amount paid till date from my balances. Please guide
  • Lalit
    Updated on
    May 10, 2012
      Really very good important information shared. Thanks a Lot.. Keep giving Us Information on all important issues...
  • Sangmesh
    Updated on
    Jul 11, 2012
      This article is very easy to understand, Happy to read this...
  • Dr Wadgave HV MO Amboli Sindhudurga
    Updated on
    Dec 27, 2012
      This is very good article Thanks for sharing
  • Vinod
    Updated on
    Dec 31, 2012
      Well written in common man understanding terms. Thank you!
  • Ayaz
    Updated on
    Jun 08, 2013
      Well explained....Straight and simple !!!

  • Post Comment

    :
       
     
     
      
       
    :
    :
    :
    * Comments are moderated by PersonalFN admin, and may not appear until they have been approved by Admin