Can a stock be valued cheaply than a bond? Or for that matter a Government bond? Looks unlikely, isn’t it? After all, a good quality stock will continue to raise its earnings for many years into the future. But a bond has no such possibility. Its coupon payments will remain as similar five years down the line as they are today.

Thus, it goes without saying that stocks will continue to trade at lower yields than Govt bonds or in other words, will command a higher P/E.

However, as we all know, markets don’t operate with robotic precision. A lot of times, stocks, even good quality ones, start to trade at prices that make them more attractive than Government bonds.

Clearly, what better opportunity for a value investor to fish in a sea of such stocks? Not only are these stocks good quality but they also have a margin of safety in the sense that they are available at lower or at par valuations of Government bonds.

In our view, stocks that are currently available at a P/E of 10 or less are the kind of stocks that could qualify for the criterion mentioned above. Why a P/E of 10? Well, a small Google search will tell us that a 10-year Indian Government bond currently trades at a yield of around 9%.

Thus, a stock with a P/E of 10 or less is the one that is trading lower than the bond. Besides, it is also important that the stock be of good quality i.e. have a D/E ratio of no more than 0.5 times so that the chances of the same going bankrupt or the stock turning into a value trap is minimized to the best extent possible.

The table shown below indicates the stocks from the mid cap universe that are not only good quality (D/E of less than 0.5) but are also trading at attractive yields.

Good quality Mid Caps cheaper than Government bonds....

Company name	Trailing 12 month P/E	Total D/E
Gujarat Narmada Valley Fertilizers Company Ltd.	3.60	0.50
Gujarat State Fertilizers & Chemicals Ltd.	4.61	0.14
Clariant Chemicals (India) Ltd.	5.68	0.00
Glodyne Technoserve Ltd.	6.84	0.29
Educomp Solutions Ltd.	6.86	0.42
Gujarat Fluorochemicals Ltd.	7.79	0.33
Housing Development & Infrastructure Ltd.	8.07	0.45
Maharashtra Seamless Ltd.	8.18	0.04
Polaris Financial Technology Ltd.	8.35	0.00
Birla Corporation Ltd.	8.94	0.50
Graphite India Ltd.	9.12	0.19
Kalpataru Power Transmission Ltd.	9.52	0.28
MOIL Ltd.	9.77	0.00

Source: Ace Equity
Note: The table excludes the name of banks and financial institutions

It should be noted that the stocks listed above can only be a good starting point to start one’s research from. Investing only on the basis of criteria given above and doing no further research may not achieve the desired results according to us.

By Equitymaster – India's leading 'independent' equity research initiative. Trusted by over a million members all over the world, Equitymaster is known for its well-researched, unbiased and honest opinions on the Indian stock markets.

Add Comments